![]() |
|
Sunday, June 12, 2005 Vol. II No. 12
Prepared by Bob Miller, ATP,
MCFI |
Welcome to the
Over the Airwaves
aviation newsletter. This complimentary bi-weekly e-mailing is
being sent to pilots and aviation enthusiasts around the world.
Its aim
is to promote flight
safety, encourage students and new pilots, and to build enthusiasm
for aviation in general.
Dear Pilots and Aviation Enthusiasts:
Commenting upon a previous issue of "Over the Airwaves," one of my flight students, David Smith from Grand Island, NY, said, "Bob, flying is a lot like operating a table saw. You do something stupid, you get hurt!" He is absolutely right! I thought about my own limited experience using a table saw. I recall being taught to always use a "push stick" instead of my hand to guide smaller pieces of wood through the spinning saw blade. I also learned, through experience, that wood contains knots and other irregularities that can cause it to buck or kickback while being cut. And using protective eye gear goes without saying.
So what does all of this have to do with flying? Instruction is required whether learning to fly or learning to safely use a table saw. Similarly, the more we fly or the more we use a table saw, the more proficient (and safe) we become. But instruction and regular use can only go so far. If a person wants to take shortcuts, he will likely get hurt. If he launches without reviewing a checklist, or if he throws on the table saw power switch without donning protective eye wear, he could be in for a big surprise. In other words, some things cannot be taught! Some people are bent on doing stupid things in airplanes . . . like flying through prohibited airspace over the nation's capital, or taking off overweight, or flying blindly into deteriorating weather, or forgetting to lower the landing gear, or not checking oil before starting up, or running out of fuel, or skipping a careful weather brief. Stupid acts defy instruction. We ALL do something stupid from time to time. We do things that we have been taught NOT to do . . . and go ahead and do them anyway! Most of the time we survive unscathed. Unfortunately, sometimes we don't. The evidence is in the NTSB Accident Reports! We know that 3/4ths of all 300 to 400 fatal GA accidents each year in the U.S. are officially attributed to pilot error. How many of these pilot error-caused accidents were a result of a pilot really doing something stupid??? You be the judge.
Each year, area
designated pilot examiners and flight instructors spend an entire
day together meeting with the FAA (Rochester FSDO) to discuss flight
safety issues, training, and regulatory matters. This year's
meeting was held earlier this week.
Among the many items
covered this year, FAA representatives discussed ten (10) areas of
flight training that requires additional emphasis by flight
instructors. These areas are:
It was a great Memorial Day morning at the Akron, NY Airport (9G3). The local Civil Air Patrol (CAP) served up a record 650 breakfasts and 160 adults and children were taken for plane rides. The weather was picture-perfect. This was aviation at its very best! The scenario is all
too familiar. A 580 hour, non-instrument rated private pilot
takes off in marginal VFR weather, enters IMC conditions, attempts a
180 degree turn back to better weather, then spins in to his death.
Such
was the case on February 22, 1994 when a Cessna 210 pilot took off
from Valley Spring, Texas. He had received several FSS weather
briefings which included a statement that "VFR flight not
recommended." The pilot launched anyway.
Probable Cause . .
.
Here's the text from
the NTSB Crash Report:
Spatial
Disorientation . . .
According to the FAA's
Civil Aviation Medical Institute (CAMI), approximately 30 general
aviation accidents a year are attributed to spatial disorientation.
Sadly, 90 percent of these accidents are fatal. That is
equivalent to one fatal spatial disorientation accident every 1.5
weeks in the United States.
Nobody is Immune to
Spatial Disorientation
Lest you think that
your extensive flight experience makes you immune from spatial
disorientation, think again. Spatial disorientation can happen
to anybody, regardless of hours of flight experience.
Understanding Why
Spatial Disorientation Occurs:
![]() We humans have three systems that keep us oriented - (1) Eyesight: This accounts for 75 to 80% of the information our mind processes. (2) Vestibular System: This is the inner ear telling us if we are upright, turning, accelerating, or decelerating. (3) Kinesthetic Sense: This is commonly called "seat-of-the-pants system." It includes our joints and body tissue feeling gravity's forces. When all three of these systems are synchronous, we feel comfortable with our attitude. It is when these systems do not agree with each other that spatial disorientation occurs. Beware of the Two Kinds of Spatial Disorientation!
Type I Spatial Disorientation - Here, the pilot is unaware that he or she is disoriented. A classic example of this occurred several years ago when an air cargo pilot took off in low visibility just as his attitude indicator failed. The AI slowly rolled to the right. Reacting visually to the instrument indication, the pilot attempted to correct it with left aileron. The airplane rolled steeply to the left, went inverted, and crashed. The only way to prevent Type I special disorientation is to continually cross check the instruments and to disregard your vestibular and kinesthetic senses. Type II Spatial Disorientation - This occurs when something doesn't "feel" right. The "leans" is a condition that instrument pilots occasionally experience. Here, pilots have the sensation that the airplane is turning when, in fact, it is flying straight and level. Of the two types of spatial disorientation, Type II is preferable in that the pilot knows something is amiss and takes specific steps to correct the problem. In this case, a solid trust in the instruments and an effective instrument scan is the best way to prevent both Type I and II spatial disorientation.
Setting the example
for every other airport and aviation special interest group in the
nation,
Akron Airport and its owners, Christian Airmen, Inc. this
week announced the awarding of two
college scholarships. The winners were Katlynn Akin (pictured
left) and Aaron Conley (pictured right), both graduating seniors
from Akron Central High School.
"I wish we could
have done more," says Larry Cummings, recent past president
of Christian Airmen, Inc. The awards, each in the amount of
$500, will be used to help offset college expenses for both Akin and
Conley. "We hope to increase the size and number of
college scholarships after we get our new Christian Airmen
Foundation underway," adds Cummings.
Katlynn will be
entering her freshman year at Daniel Webster College in New
Hampshire and Aaron will enter Genesee Community College this
September. Both students are planning to become professional
airline pilots.
![]()
Both
Katlynn and Aaron were participants in the Introduction to
Aviation class which I began teaching at the Akron High
School last September. A new class will be forming this coming
September.
The Future of
Aviation Resides in its Youth!
Of the 4,600 airports
in the United States, those that are thriving are those where MORE
young people than old people are seen hanging around!
There are many ways to
attract young people (future pilots) to your local airport.
One is through an active Civil Air Patrol program. Another is
by having an active flight training program. Another is by
conducting "Introduction to Aviation" classes at
nearby high schools.
Click HERE to view the photo album of our flight to Sun 'n Fun 2005!
Sadly,
the wrong fuel type, contaminated fuel, or not receiving as much
fuel as ordered has caused far too many fatal aircraft accidents.
Fortunately, such fueling errors are easy to spot . . . IF you take
the time to do it! It's difficult to imagine how somebody might mistakenly fill a Piper Cub or Cessna 152 with JET A. It happens, particularly around large, busy airports where minimum wage fuel truck operators try to stay ahead of the game on a busy ramp. This problem has the potential for becoming far worse as more turbo-prop (not to be confused with turbo-charged) general aviation airplanes appear on the market. Some turbocharged aircraft owners have removed "Turbocharged" labels from the sides of their airplanes to minimize inadvertent fueling with JET-A! Check the Fuel Color No student pilot ever gets into the cockpit without first sumping the tanks and checking for fuel color and contaminants. The rest of us certainly should be doing the same thing . . . but do we always? Remember, fuel color isn't always easy to detect. Dyes are purposefully put into different grades of AVGAS as a final check for pilots. Sometimes these dyes become excessively diluted so the color isn't readily apparent. So check carefully. Quick Check for JET A You can quickly check for the presence of JET A in your tanks by draining several drops of sumpted fuel on a piece of paper. JET A will leave a permanent oil stain on the paper. Pure AVGAS, on the other hand, will evaporate and leave no stain.
Leave the Beacon or Strobes ALWAYS on! One of the best ways to prevent leaving the master switch on is to always leave your beacon and/or strobe light switch on. Some pilots have gone so far as to duct tape these switches in the "on" position. Then, when you leave the airplane, turn around . . . if you see your beacon or strobes flashing, you'll instantly know that the master switch was left on!
Burt Rutan and Mike Melvill of White Knight/SpaceShipOne; Actor and pilot Harrison Ford, Chairman of the EAA Young Eagles Program; Steve Fossett, world record-setting pilot of the Virgin Atlantic GlobalFlyer; Will Whitehorn, President of Virgin Galactic, which is working on creating the space tourism industry; Sir Richard Branson, founder/chairman of the Virgin Companies; Scott Crossfield, legendary test pilot; Peter Diamandis, Chairman of the X Prize Foundation; and Bob Cardin, one of the leaders of the P-38 Glacier Girl project.
In addition, there
will be a one-of-a-kind reunion of World War II bombers including
Click HERE to open a directory of all past, present, and current issues of "Over the Airwaves." Once you have this site open, save it as a "favorite" in your Internet browser. Once done, you'll always have access to the current (and past issues) of "Over the Airwaves."
Believe it or not, mid-air collisions between airliners (30 seats or more) were fairly common between the years of 1946 and 1978. Back then, there was an average of one fatal collision a year, but today they are virtually non-existent. Mid-airs between airliners are non-existent because of (1) on-board Traffic Collision Avoidance System (TCAS), (2) corresponding ATC equipment, and (3) the requirement to be equipped with Mode C in airspace around the nation's busiest commercial airports.
There have been 329 recorded mid-air collisions between general aviation aircraft between the years 1983 and 2000, according to FAA's Office of Accident Investigation. While decreasing over the past 30 years, the mid-air collision rate has stabilized at an average of 16 per year. Here are several conclusions drawn by the FAA regarding mid-air collisions:
Looking out the window, using your radio, transponder with Mode C on, and proper traffic pattern procedures are the four best things we can do to prevent a mid-air collision.
Thunderstorm season is here! This is the time of the year when many TAF (Terminal Aerodrome Forecast) contains ominous warnings of thunderstorms somewhere along your planned route of flight. What do you do? Do you cancel your trip in hopes of better weather on another day? Do you plan a wide diversion around areas containing forecasts of thunderstorm activity? Do you cast your fate to the wind and blast off in the face of forecast thunderstorms? Tough questions, all! Become Thunderstorm Savvy! Understanding the three stages of thunderstorm development is a good starting point in becoming thunderstorm savvy! Each of these three stages are summarized below. Underlined links to images of each stage are included (courtesy of the College of DuPage Weather Staff). Cumulus Stage: Graph , Picture
Dissipating Stage: Graph , Picture
It is a simple fact of aviation life that thunderstorms, actual or "chance of", will appear in many METAR/TAFs during the hot summer months. Fortunately for the VFR pilot, most of them will be readily visible and easily avoided. The IFR pilot, on the other hand, faces a different problem. Thunderstorms embedded in instrument meteorological conditions (IMC) cannot be seen without onboard radar or spherics equipment. The Best Solution . . . Become thunderstorm savvy by reading everything you can on the subject. Become a junior meteorologist. Once you know the facts of thunderstorm life, you will be a much safer pilot! Simple Rule of Thumb! Anytime the dew point is above 70 degrees F (21 degrees C), beware of thunderstorms forming! Student pilots . . . beware! Your pilot examiner will expect you to explain the inner workings of the engine that powers your airplane, including number of cylinders, required fuel grade, horsepower, oil capacity, etc. This is not only important for checkrides, this knowledge could also help you to diagnose an in-flight problem with your engine. The Four Strokes of an Internal Combustion Engine: The basic principle for
reciprocating engines involves the conversion of chemical
energy, in the form of fuel, into mechanical energy. This occurs
within the cylinders of the engine through a process known as
the four-stroke operating cycle. These strokes are called 2. Compression: The compression stroke begins when the intake valve closes and the piston starts moving back to the top of the cylinder. This phase of the cycle is used to obtain a much greater power output from the fuel/air mixture once it is ignited. 3. Power: The power stroke begins when the fuel/air mixture is ignited. This causes a tremendous pressure increase in the cylinder, and forces the piston downward away from the cylinder head, creating the power that turns the crankshaft. 4. Exhaust: The exhaust stroke is used to purge the cylinder of burned gases. It begins when the exhaust valve opens and the piston starts to move toward the cylinder head once again. Be sure you know these four strokes along with each of the other "systems" that operate your airplane.
It was one of those beautiful Sunday mornings for a VFR training flight. My student, young Katlynn Akin, a high school senior, was at the controls. My training goal for this lesson was to provide Katlynn with the skills to safely recover from a spin. The typical spin recovery training follows a predictable format. The instructor pitches the airplane to its critical angle of attack causing the airplane to stall, then kicks a rudder to produce the necessary yaw which puts the airplane into a spin. He then tells the student to recover. Again, this is all very predictable and not very realistic. To make spin recovery training effective, it has to be unpredictable! To be effective, I wanted the spin to come as a surprise to Katlynn. To do this, I asked her to make the airplane fly as slow as possible without losing altitude. She responded appropriately by first performing her clearing turns, then reducing power, extending the flaps, and holding back pressure on the yoke. As the pitch angle increased, Katlynn found it necessary to add power to maintain altitude. The airspeed reduced with each additional increase in power. Operating well behind the power curve, she discovered that the slowest airspeed required maximum power. Now operating several knots above stall speed, I instructed Katlynn to make a 90 degree turn to the left. Out of control!! Katlynn rolled into a 30 degree bank. As she did so, the stall speed correspondingly increased. Noting a sudden loss of altitude, Katlynn pitched up and attempted to level the wings with yoke. That's when she lost control of the airplane. The four left turning tendencies (P-factor, slip stream, torque, and gyroscopic forces) were all working together to pull the airplane to the left as she pitched up and attempted to roll right. Katlynn's action produced a massive yawing moment that resulted in a sudden and unexpected (to her, not me) spin. The left wing fell out from under us and the nose dropped 60 degrees as the airplane began to spin around its pivot point. Katlynn frantically turned the yoke in the opposite direction, but to no avail. As far as Katlynn was concerned, the airplane was totally out of control and losing altitude fast. All we saw out the front window was the rapidly revolving ground below! The spin recovery was immediate . . . I simply reduced the power to idle, neutralized the ailerons, pressed hard on the right rudder, then pressed forward on the yoke. The airplane instantly stopped spinning and rolled out into straight and level flight. We devoted the remainder of our three hour flight lesson repeating this maneuver. By the end of the 10th cross-controlled stall/spin entry, Katlynn mastered the fine art of proper spin recovery. She instinctively knew what to do and in what order to do it in. With this critical skill under her belt, Katlynn will likely never become a victim of an unexpected stall/spin event! In summary, the training scenario was unexpected (to Katlynn). And it was real, rather than some deliberately set up maneuver to "simulate" a stall/spin event. And the training left a lasting impression . . . and one which will serve her well throughout her flying career.
The recently released 2004 Nall Report, the definitive report published by the AOPA Air Safety Foundation on general aviation accidents in the previous year, continues to affirm the fact that three-quarters of all GA accidents are attributed to pilot error!
If these data do not send shivers down the spine of every GA pilot, then something is seriously wrong. As shown in the table above (source: 2004 Nall Report), 1,147 pilots screwed up badly enough in the year 2003 to have an accident. Worse, 236 pilots screwed up badly enough to kill themselves and/or at least one passenger in the process! While the human loss is tragic in itself, think about needless destruction of perfectly good airplanes. If that doesn't frost you, think about the millions of dollars in law suits and resultant insurance company payouts that resulted. Remember, every insurance payout is recouped by the insurance companies in subsequent policy holder premiums. Simple Fact of Life If the FAA and the AOPA and its Air Safety Foundation cannot affect a significant reduction in this GA accident rate, the solution must come from us as individual pilots and flight instructors. Each of us must take definitive steps to significantly reduce the probability that any of us will be involved in an accident. The only way to accomplish this is to follow similar training protocols used by airline pilots. This means securing meaningful professional level training EVERY year. By professional level training I mean engaging the best flight instructor you can find and going out and sharpening your stick and rudder skills, going through the entire stall series, unusual attitude recovery exercises, spin recovery training, bounced/ballooned, and cross-wind landings. And learn to land precisely on the centerline with your nose pointed directly down the runway! Instrument pilots . . . we have an even more demanding recurrent training requirement. The six/six rule (six approaches in six months, etc.) is not enough. Get out in the low IFR weather and (with or without a CFII aboard) practice landing to ILS minimums. In addition, each of us should devote at least six hours every year to aeronautical decision making and risk management scenario training. Remember, practice make permanent . . . not perfect! Going out by yourself and practicing takeoffs and landings doesn't always cut it. Instead, secure the services of a trained eye to insure that you are practicing proper techniques. Remember, accidents happen to pilots at all experience levels, from the primary student to the 20,000 hour ATP. No, we cannot change the national GA accident rates. But we can dramatically reduce the probability that we, ourselves, will be involved in an aviation accident.
"I'm an airline pilot with
a major U.S. carrier, but flying old taildraggers and warbirds
is my passion. I appreciate your newsletter's honest attitude
and common sense, informative articles on safety." Click HERE to read a letter received this past week from Brian Binns from Southern California. Brian relates a miraculous spin recovery experience that came very close to taking his life! Click HERE to view what other readers have had to say about "Over the Airwaves!"
Over the Airwaves is not intended to be your typical training, official news, or
club-type social journal. Instead, its intent is to stimulate
thought, enhance aviation critical thinking skills, to encourage the
strong pilot, and to disturb the weaker pilot. With this
breadth of scope, Over the Airwaves will evoke a number of
reactions. Please feel free to share these reactions with me
by clicking
HERE.
Past Issues of
Click
HERE
to open any
previous issue(s) of Over the Airwaves and to search
for any past articles.
|